2013 Reports & Tribunal Discusion

That would severely affect Central as far as lack of height goes, wouldn't it Phil?

bayman wrote:i'm not sure how much truth is in this but i've heard if Craig Parry gets reported & found guilty his career finishes immediately...is this correct ? so he could call an umpire a name get reported, found guilty & career over (it will be in October but that's another story)

That is correct, about Parry, I believe. Is a 1 game suspension away from being de-registered from playing any footy, at all.

Big Phil wrote:

bayman wrote:i'm not sure how much truth is in this but i've heard if Craig Parry gets reported & found guilty his career finishes immediately...is this correct ? so he could call an umpire a name get reported, found guilty & career over (it will be in October but that's another story)

That is correct, about Parry, I believe. Is a 1 game suspension away from being de-registered from playing any footy, at all.

A JOKE

bayman wrote:

Big Phil wrote:

bayman wrote:i'm not sure how much truth is in this but i've heard if Craig Parry gets reported & found guilty his career finishes immediately...is this correct ? so he could call an umpire a name get reported, found guilty & career over (it will be in October but that's another story)

That is correct, about Parry, I believe. Is a 1 game suspension away from being de-registered from playing any footy, at all.

A JOKE

Well, he has had something like 15 games out suspended over the course of his whole senior career. That's almost a whole season missed via suspension !!! You do the crime, you do the time. If you can't learn the lesson, then the punishment has to be extreme...

why does it in your words have ''to be extreme'' ? (each case as with the law should be separate)

if he 'clocks' someone, he gets 3 or 4 or whatever not a life sentence, imho it isn't the right thing to do.....it is almost like New York (i think it's New York) with the 3 strikes penalty with crime & your locked up for good

I can see both sides to the argument, Bayman. If 'serial' offenders keep on doing the wrong thing, how else are they going to learn?

Big Phil wrote:I can see both sides to the argument, Bayman. If 'serial' offenders keep on doing the wrong thing, how else are they going to learn?

lengthier penalties, every club would not put up with players (no matter how good or pivotal they are) being sidelined for a fair chunk of the season

Alan Obst has accepted the 4 week suspension, according to the Doggies' Facebook page...

CDFC Facebook Page wrote:
Legal Representation from the club has advised that Alan Obst has accepted the 4 week suspension handed down to him by the IRP

I'm with bayman on this. Each case should be treated on its merits. And I still have trouble coming to terms with the fact that if you try to defend your actions and the tribunal doesn't like your defence, you suddenly become more guilty, and get another game. Who thought that up?

Obviously the incident involving Todd Miles and James Boyd has been caught on camera...

http://www.sanfl.com.au/news/sanfl_news/2082/

Zac Milbank wrote:North Adelaide co-captain Todd Miles has been offered a one-match ban for misconduct against Central District’s James Boyd in Sunday’s match at Prospect Oval. He has until 9am Tuesday to decide whether to accept or challenge the ban.

North Acting Co-Captain Todd Miles is going to challenge the tribunal's 1 match suspension handed down, earlier...

on the SANFL site, Zac Milbank wrote:

Sin Bin
Acting North Adelaide co-captain Todd Miles will challenge his one-match ban for misconduct on Central’s James Boyd at Prospect Oval on Sunday. His hearing will take place at 6pm on Tuesday.
Port Adelaide forward Graham Johncock has accepted a reprimand for engaging in rough conduct with Norwood captain Kieran McGuinness at Alberton Oval on Saturday.

The Roosters challenge of Todd Miles' 1 week ban was successful and he is free to play against Sturt on Saturday...

in a tweet, the SANFL wrote:
@SANFLnews: @NorthAdelaideFC Todd Miles has been found Not Guilty by the SANFL Tribunal and is free to play this weekend.

That is good news for the Roosters, as Miles will be needed this week against an in-form Double Blues...

Central District forward Alan Obst has again let the Dogs down by being reported in the Reserves last week and offered a 3 week ban...

http://www.sanfl.com.au/news/sanfl_news/2197/

He seems to be a serial pest Big Phil.

How close is he now to the 16 match disqualification?

the prowler wrote:How close is he now to the 16 match disqualification?

Depends on whether the CDFC accept the 3 weeks or fight it?
At a guess, prior to this current report, I would suggest he would be at about 8 or 9 weeks in total?

I was wondering that too prowler
I have 5 games missed for league since 2011, but I dont have records for ressies or underage comps

Waldhuter offered 2 weeks, Barmby a reprimand for pushing the North runner, the North runner a $300 fine for his part in it and Kriston Thompson offered 1 week for his hit on Schiller in the reserves on Saturday...

http://www.sanfl.com.au/news/sanfl_news/2246/

The league penalties seem fair enough to me, however, given the recent poor behaviour of various North Adelaide runners over the past couple of seasons, the SANFL should be considering handing the club a fine as well, or at the very least a warning to the club that any subsequent runner altercations will result in heavy sanctions against the club and/or the suspension of the runner (ie a week where North has no runner).

Thompson very lucky to be only getting one IMO.

Lawton offered 5 games

bayman wrote:Lawton offered 5 games

What did he do?

Kill someone.

BloodnTars wrote:

bayman wrote:Lawton offered 5 games

What did he do?

Kill someone.

apparently

to be honest the incident was over 100 metres from me, from there i thought it was 2 blokes going for the ball & the Sturt player came off worse for wear, however he was obviously concussed with blood coming out presumably from his nose as he was helped from the arena, if the replay shows he raised his arm/elbow etc then yep throw the book at him..............for the record both teams in the first half were niggling, punching & at times being spiteful etc & off the ball & it settled down a fair bit after half time