Talking Footy SA Player of the Year

We'll be running a TFSA "Player of the Year' competition. There'll be a small prize and we'll try to arrange for the winning player to receive the trophy from one of our posters here who supports the winner's club.

It will be on a 3,2,1 basis and we're calling for volunteers from each club to assist with the voting when they can.

If you want to be involved, let us know here. We're happy for as many to be involved as want to be.

Is the voting going to be done by a panel of regulars, or will every poster be able to vote and the votes collectively tallied to form the 3,2,1?

Awesome idea. I'll be available to do many of the TV matches (if it's shown ) if allowed that way. If only by someone at the game rules me out not living in Adelaide.

Bt, I think any poster can have a say and perhaps those who have volunteered can judge the consensus.

This still happening?

Yes, sapaul, it is.

Voting will be 3,2,1 and we'll open it up to all posters to give their votes if they wish.

On (say) Wednesdays, the panel will consider those votes and make a final judgement.

At this stage, if they are willing, the judges will be sapaul, Brucetike and anyone else who volunteers by this Tuesday night.

So give some votes or volunteer to judge as well and we'll see how we go.

I'll start off with west v south:

3 Willits
2 Ezard
1 Still

Unlucky: Stribling, Liddle, Caire, Green, N Caruso, F Caruso.

Port Adelaide v W/WT

3. J. Clayton (PA)
2. R. McKenzie (PA)
1. J. Hoskin (PA)

West Adelaide v South Adelaide

3. D. Caire (WA)
2. A. Fielke (WA)
1. S.Birss (WA)

West Adelaide v South Adelaide

3...Caire
2...Fielke
1...Willets

testy wrote:

West Adelaide v South Adelaide

3...Caire
2...Fielke
1...Willets

Have to agree

Port Adelaide vs Woodvile-West Torrens

3. J Clayton (PA)
2. B Ebert (PA)
1. L Thompson (WWT)

I think the consensus is as follows:

West v South

3 D Caire (WA)
2 A Fielke (WA)
1 R Willits (WA)


Port v Eagles

3 J Clayton (PA)
2 B McKenzie (PA)
1 B Ebert (PA)

Open to discussion, otherwise we'll go with that.

Round 2 votes:

Sturt v Port Adelaide:

3. Adam Thomson (Sturt)
2. Tim McIntyre (Sturt)
1. Sam Gray (Port Adelaide)

Norwood v Central District

3. Nathan Batsanis (Norwood)
2. Kieran McGuinness (Norwood)
1. James Boyd (Central)

[quote="C.K"]Round 2 votes:

Sturt v Port Adelaide:

3. Adam Thomson (Sturt)
2. Tim McIntyre (Sturt)
1. Sam Gray (Port Adelaide)

Norwood v Central District

3. Nathan Batsanis (Norwood)
2. Kieran McGuinness (Norwood)
1. James Boyd (Central)



I'll second those votes.

Only saw the TV Game.

3 - Matthew Rose (Port)
2 - Tim McIntyre (Sturt)
1 - Matthew Jaensch (Sturt)

Glenelg v West

3 Tenace (G)
2 Hender (G)
1 Green (W)

Glenelg V West

3...Tenace (G)
2...Hender (G)
1...Ezard (W)

OK, final result:

Sturt v Port

3 Thompson (St)
2 McIntyre (St)
1 Rose (PA)


Glenelg v West

3 Tenace (G)
2 Hender (G)
1 Green (WA)

I'll sort out the other 2 games soon.

Norwood v Central final:

3 Batsanis (N)
2 McGuinness (N)
1 Boyd (CD)

South v North final:

No votes have been recorded, so I'll put up a vote and leave time for comments or alterations until tomorrow morning.

3 Ainger (SA)
2 Alleway (NA)
1 Brown (SA)

Round 3: West v Central District

3. J. Beech (West)
2. R. Willits (West)
1. P. Marschall (CD)

C.K wrote:Round 3: West v Central District

3. J. Beech (West)
2. R. Willits (West)
1. P. Marschall (CD)

Your new favourite Dogs player, CK?

3 Symes (CD)
2 Beech (WA)
1 Hartlett (WA)

3 Beech (WA)
2 Hartlett (WA)
1 Marschall (CD)

West v Central

3. C.Schmidt (WA)
2. B.Crouch (WA)
1. P.Marschall (CD)





South v Sturt

3. B.Martin (St)
2. N.Liddle (SA)
1. J.Jenkins (St)




Norwood v Eagles

3. S.Phillips (Nwd)
2. T.Webber (Nwd)
1. P.Raymond (WWT)